Stevie's Famous
Justin’s Score: 9.2
Location: Phinney Ridge / Beacon Hill / Burien
Style: New York Style
Description: Reviewed Stevie's with Michelin Star Chef Johnny Spero. We were both blown away by the quality and texture of the pizza. I love the sourdough crust, it makes it healthier and gives the pizza such a unique flavor. A true taste of NYC inside of SEA.
AK Pizza
Justin’s Score: 9.1
Location: 6901 Martin Luther King Jr Way S Suite A, Seattle, WA 98118
Style: Seattle Style
Description: Owner Alex Kim recently opened his own shop and seems to be leading the pizza game in Seattle. He has worked at various pizza shops in Seattle and decided to start his own. AK Pizza is ran by a true pizza scientist. Crunchy, char heavy, and delicious.
MOTO Pizza
Justin’s Score: 8.8
Location: Various Locations (Seattle, WA)
Style: Detroit Style
Description: MOTO Pizza started out of a home in West Seattle. They had extreme demand for a long time and you had to order months in advance to secure a pizza. In 2026, they now have multiple locations including a location inside of T Mobile Park where the Mariners play. Won the Randazzo Award for "Best Detroit Style Pizza" in the World at the 2026 International Pizza Expo. I have had MOTO many times before and when we went to review it at T Mobile Park, it held up to my standards (even as a ballpark pizza). Crispy edges and gooey cheese all melts in your mouth. We got the classic cheese but they have some "Odd Pizza" offerings like a crab pie.
Post Alley Pizza
Justin’s Score: 8.3
Location: 1123 Post Ave, Seattle, WA 98101 (Pike Place Market)
Style: Seattle Style
Description: Post Alley has unbeatable crunch and zero flop. This thing has so much structure I was questioning my own life decisions. Everything fresh, everything clean. I've heard the sandos are pretty damn good too.
Un Po Tipsy
Justin’s Score: 8.2
Location: 419 Occidental Ave S, Seattle, WA 98104 (Pioneer Square/SODO)
Style: Seattle Style
Description: Un Po Tipsy was quote "crunchy as hell." Located one block from Lumen Field and located inside of Lowlander Brewing, this is the perfect game day spot. I would say this competes with some of the best in NYC.
Cornelly
Justin’s Score: 8.2
Location: Seattle WA (Capitol Hill & Queen Anne)
Style: Seattle Sourdough Style
Description: Cornelly's sourdough crust and crunch set it apart from most of the pizza spots in Seattle. The cheese to sauce ratio or CTSR leans a bit more on the cheese side of things, but in a good way. The C&C (chew and crunch) are both excellent and the vibes are immaculate. Super friendly spot. Only $22 for a cheese pie!
The Independent Pizzeria
Justin’s Score: 8.1
Location: 4235 E Madison St, Seattle, WA 98112 (Madison Park)
Style: Wood-Fired Vibes
Description: Owner operated in Madison Park, The Indepenent serves chewy, charred, and delicious pizzas. I frequented this spot when I was living in Capitol Hill. The sauce to cheese ratio is perfect and the vibes are immaculate.
Slice Box
Justin’s Score: 8.1
Location: 1727 1st Ave S, Seattle, WA 98134 (SODO)
Style: Seattle Style
Description: Right down the street from T Mobile park sleeps a sleeps a friendly pizza beast. Slice Box is doing it right and the owner Ryan is a great guy. Grungy and grimey vibes inside the building and crunchy yet soft vibes inside the box. Seattle is a pizza city AND a sports city.
Roma Roma
Justin’s Score: 7.9
Location: 1610 12th Ave, Seattle, WA 98122 (Capitol Hill)
Style: Roman Style
Description: Roma Roma opened in Feb 2026 and quickly rose to the top of my list. The crunch on this pie was insane. Definitely a date night spot as the vibes are "sexy" inside the spot. If you are looking to impress that special someone, Roma Roma is a good play.
My Friend Derek's
Justin’s Score: 7.8
Location: 2108 N 55th St, Seattle, WA 98103 (Green Lake)
Style: Detroit Style
Description: My friend Derek's started in a townhome in Fremont. Derek himself would bake his signature Detroit style pies and schedule with his friends to come pick them up. It is a true example of the American (Seattle) Dream. The edges are crunchy and the dough is perfectly chewy. A great story and an even greater pizza.
Tivoli
Justin’s Score: 7.7
Location: 30 N 34th St, Seattle, WA 98103 (Fremont)
Style: Wood Fired Seattle Style
Description: Tivoli is regarded as one of the best pies in Seattle. When I went it was near closing time and I think they'd usually get a higher score. Some of the best flavors in town. I stand by a 7.7 on that day but I could easily see how it would get into the 8's
Petoskey's
Justin’s Score: 7.7
Location: 125 N 36th St, Seattle, WA 98103 (Fremont)
Style: Tavern Style
Description: I was drunk when I gave this score but I stand by it. Petoskey's is a great tavern pie and a great place to watch the game. The oven is wood fired and they serve slices as well.
DUDE'Z Pizza
Justin’s Score: 7.7
Location: 2919 Fuhrman Ave E, Seattle, WA 98102 (Portage Bay)
Style: Wood-Fired
Description: DUDE'Z Serves up wood fired pies in Portage Bay and has expanded all the way to Auburn. Perfect spot for a solid wood fired pie. They are super reasonably priced and the chew is perfect.
The Neighborhood Bar & Grill
Justin’s Score: 7.6
Location: 6503 California Ave SW, Seattle, WA 98136 (West Seattle)
Style: Bar Pie
Description: The Neighborhood is a solid spot in West Seattle. It smelled like Chuck E Cheese coming out of the box (in a good way). I would highly recommend for checking out a big game and getting a solid pie.
Swing Sandwiches & Pizza
Justin’s Score: 7.5
Location: 223 W Galer St suite a, Seattle, WA 98119 (Queen Anne)
Style: Seattle Style
Description: Swing pizza serves some of the best pizza and sandwiches in the city. The bathroom is also extremely luxurious. I was surprised they did not have a bidet in there tbh. I've been dying to go back and try another pie.
Capitale Pizzeria
Justin’s Score: 7.5
Location: 426 Broadway E, Seattle, WA 98102 (Capitol Hill)
Style: Neapolitan
Description: Neapolitan is admittedly not my favorite style, but Capitale does it right. They serve different pizza creations from around the world and you can tell they are made very fresh.
Fremont Pizza
Justin’s Score: 7.4
Location: Fremont
Style: Seattle Style
Description: If you’re in Fremont and want an easy win, Fremont Pizza is a solid spot to hit. It used to be Ian’s, so a lot of people already know the vibe, and it still delivers on that same quick, satisfying slice. Good variety, solid quality, and right in the middle of everything, so it just makes sense when you’re in the area. Not overhyped, just a dependable Fremont go to.
Danitini
Justin’s Score: 7.4
Location: 417 Elliott Ave W, Seattle, WA 98119 (Interbay)
Style: Seattle Style
Description: Dantini was my go to spot for a while long before I started these reveiews. The merch is awesome and the pizzas are even better. I would highly recommend for anyone looking for a nice grab and go option. I think I would go back and give this 7.9 if I could.
Dino's
Justin’s Score: 7.2
Location: Capitol Hill
Style: Seattle Style
Description: If you want a no nonsense, classic slice in Seattle, Dino's Pizza is one of those divey spots that just delivers every time. Big slices, crispy crust, solid toppings, and it actually feels like you’re getting your money’s worth. It’s casual.. a little gritty in the best way and perfect whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or ending a night out. Not trying to be fancy, just pretty good pizza. Their website says "The Second Best Pizza In Seattle"
Pagliacci
Justin’s Score: 7.1
Location: Chain with many locations
Style: Seattle Style
Description: This is good chain pizza and a Seattle favorite. Great for grabbing a slice or whole pie while in a pinch. Super reliable and super flavorful.
Hot Mama's
Justin’s Score: 7.1
Location: Capitol Hill
Style: Seattle Style
Description: If you want a go to pizza spot that never misses, Hot Mama's Pizza is always a solid move. Big slices, tons of flavor, and that pesto they’re known for actually lives up to the hype. It’s one of those places you end up going back to without even thinking about it. Easy, reliable, and straight up good pizza.
Windy City Pie
Justin’s Score: 6.8
Location: 5918 Phinney Ave N, Seattle, WA 98103 (Phinney Ridge)
Style: Chicago Deep Dish & Tavern Style
Description: Serving up true chicago classics on Phinney Ridge, Windy City Pie is the place to be. It was rocking when I went in with families and friends alike. The tavern wasn't bad but apparently I need to go back for the deep dish which they are known for.
Pallino
Justin’s Score: 5.7
Location: SEATAC Airport
Style: Airport Style
Description: It's airport pizza.
Seattle Is A Pizza City Shop
Seattle Is A Pizza City